My Info

Donna Halstead Profile Photo

Donna L. Halstead

 SL3437137 
 Realtor®  
Your Local, Professional Connection to Florida Keys Living!

I grew up on the Jersey Shore where houses had charm and character. I love houses, all houses! It doesn’t matter what the year, style, design, location, condition, décor or the lack of. I love walking through and thinking of its history, possibilities, past residents and future ones to be. Being around the water all my life led me to want to live an island lifestyle. For me, there was no better place to choose that life than The Florida Keys where you can be perpetually outdoors everyday (Jersey had snow, not good for an island girl in flip flops). 

A real estate career was a natural choice for me. Finding the right location and the right home for someone inspires me. I love finding the perfect match and the feeling of having some small part in what your biggest financial decision could be. I know how finances can affect families daily. When I was young my mother, a single mom with four kids, was elected County Comptroller for decades and she instilled in me a strong sense of responsibility and a solid work ethic. 

Her influence nurtured my analytical trait which has served me well in my career. I listen to my clients and then listen some more and can look at a home from multiple aspects and offer solutions that are sometimes outside the box. I provide you with different perspectives that can bring calm to chaos and focus on what is important to you. Your input helps me guide you to the perfect home in the perfect location for you. 

As a business owner and former Crime Analyst, I hold the numbers in high regard as well. Whether it’s completing a valuation on the home you want to sell or buy, I have a laser focus on the dollars. I’m fair but can be tough and I believe in value to all parties. Nothing makes your transaction better than having everyone walk away with a positive outcome. 

In the community I support animal shelters and rescue groups in the area. I’ve worked with the South Florida SPCA on large animal rescue and support the Paws Patrol of S. Miami. I do this because, just like people, I believe every animal deserves a great home as well. 

I look forward to meeting you if you are considering a home purchase or sale in the Lower Keys. 

    


 

What my clients are saying (3)

My Service Ratings

01/20/2026 - John R.

Donna was amazing and is a pleasure to work with. Ryan was super helpful and amazing as well.


My Service Ratings

07/16/2024 - Steven & Debbie M.

I met Donna when she was showing a house on my street. We became friends and I am so happy that I chose her to represent me in selling my home.


My Service Ratings

06/20/2023 - Jegen Family

Donna is hands down the BEST real estate person we have ever had, and we’ve used a lot of different people throughout our sale & purchases over the year. She is truly the best.

Active Listings (3)

Property Address Details
29562 Saratoga Avenue Property Photo 1
29562 Saratoga Avenue
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 2,310
47 Sadowski Property Photo 1
47 Sadowski
Key Colony, FL 33051
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,040
100 Ave I 6 Property Photo 1
100 Ave I 6
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0

Recent Listings Sold (21)

Property Address Details
22542 Jolly Roger Drive Property Photo 1
22542 Jolly Roger Drive
Cudjoe, FL 33042
Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 2,440
29569 Independence Avenue Property Photo 1
29569 Independence Avenue
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,008
29147 Cactus Lane Property Photo 1
29147 Cactus Lane
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,299
29552 Independence Avenue Property Photo 1
29552 Independence Avenue
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,280
29839 Newfound Boulevard Property Photo 1
29839 Newfound Boulevard
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 3
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,750
29559 Ranger Avenue Property Photo 1
29559 Ranger Avenue
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 1,200
873 Indies Road Property Photo 1
873 Indies Road
Ramrod, FL 33042
Bed(s): 3
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,081
73 Coral Lane Property Photo 1
73 Coral Lane
Key Colony, FL 33051
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,290
307 Sombrero Boulevard 1 Property Photo 1
307 Sombrero Boulevard 1
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 1,190
23 Palm Drive Property Photo 1
23 Palm Drive
Saddle Bunch, FL 33040
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,090
29853 Frostproof Road Property Photo 1
29853 Frostproof Road
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,232
1873 109th Street Gulf Property Photo 1
1873 109th Street Gulf
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 1,450
307 Sombrero Boulevard, 1 Property Photo 1
307 Sombrero Boulevard, 1
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 1,190
29156 Tulip Lane Property Photo 1
29156 Tulip Lane
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 912
1115 Sombrero Boulevard, 203a Property Photo 1
1115 Sombrero Boulevard, 203a
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,056
303 Sombrero Boulevard, 208 Property Photo 1
303 Sombrero Boulevard, 208
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 1
Bath(s): 1
sqft: 587
301 Sombrero Boulevard, 203 Property Photo 1
301 Sombrero Boulevard, 203
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 1
Bath(s): 1
sqft: 587
24397 W Caribbean Drive Property Photo 1
24397 W Caribbean Drive
Summerland, FL 33042
IS - Improved Subivision Zoning | 0.14 Acre(s)
35 Sombrero Boulevard, B3 Property Photo 1
35 Sombrero Boulevard, B3
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0
100 Avenue I, 6 Property Photo 1
100 Avenue I, 6
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0
31380 Ave G Property Photo 1
31380 Ave G
Big Pine, FL 33043
IS - Improved Subivision Zoning | 0.11 Acre(s)

Recent Buyer Sales (10)

Property Address Details
29569 Independence Avenue Property Photo 1
29569 Independence Avenue
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,008
29147 Cactus Lane Property Photo 1
29147 Cactus Lane
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,299
307 Sombrero Boulevard, 1 Property Photo 1
307 Sombrero Boulevard, 1
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 3
sqft: 1,190
100 Avenue I, 6 Property Photo 1
100 Avenue I, 6
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0
132 E Cahill Court Property Photo 1
132 E Cahill Court
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 3
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,388
109 Avenue D, 310 Property Photo 1
109 Avenue D, 310
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 925
109 Stirrup Key Woods Road, 1a2 Property Photo 1
109 Stirrup Key Woods Road, 1a2
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 2
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,176
6 Red Legs Lane Property Photo 1
6 Red Legs Lane
Cudjoe Key, FL 33042
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0
1563 Lantana Lane Property Photo 1
1563 Lantana Lane
Big Pine, FL 33043
Bed(s): 3
Bath(s): 2
sqft: 1,456
100 Avenue I, 6 Property Photo 1
100 Avenue I, 6
Marathon, FL 33050
Bed(s): 0
Bath(s): 0

Contact Me